The Twin City Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race first run in 1884 at Sheepshead Bay Race Track in Sheepshead Bay, New York where it continued annually through 1909. Following passage by the New York State Legislature of the Hart–Agnew Law anti-wagering bill that resulted in the closure of all racetracks in the state of New York. The devastation to the horse racing industry was such that the Sheepshead Bay Race Track never reopened. On September 2, 1909 Olambala won what would prove to be the final running of the Twin City Handicap at the Sheepshead Bay track.
In 1917 the Coney Island Jockey Club, operators of the Sheepshead Bay Race Track, transferred their race titles to The Jockey Club. As a result, in 1924 Belmont Park revived the Twin City Handicap. Won by Spot Cash, the first event at Belmont Park was run on a track made sloppy by a heavy rainstorm that the jockeys and their horses had to endure. Although the next few years saw the race continue to attract top level runners, the Wall Street Crash of October 29, 1929 and ensuing Great Depression brought further setbacks to horse racing and the race would be canceled. The final running of the Twin City Handicap took place on September 11, 1930, when future U.S. Racing Hall of Fame inductee Raymond Workman guided James Butler's three-year-old colt Questionnaire to a two-length victory while being eased up.
Records Speed record: 2:02 4/5 – miles on dirt: Questionnaire (1930)
Most wins: 3 – Exile (1888, 1889)
Most wins by a jockey: 5 – Anthony Hamilton (1886, 1888, 1889, 1892, 1894)
Most wins by a trainer: 2 – Green B. Morris (1885, 1891) 2 – William Lakeland (1888, 1889) 2 – John Rogers (1892, 1894) 2 – James G. Rowe Sr. (1896, 1905) 2 – Frank M. Taylor (1903, 1907)
Most wins by an owner: 2 – Green B. Morris (1885, 1891) 2 – William Lakeland (1888, 1889) 2 – Lucky Baldwin (1893, 1895)
Winners Year Winner Age Jockey Trainer Owner Dist. (Furlongs) Time Win$1930Questionnaire3Raymond WorkmanAndy SchuttingerJames Butler10 F2:02.80$3,8751929Petee-Wrack4Steve O'DonnellWilliam M. BoothJohn R. Macomber10 F2:03.60$4,1731928Sortie2George SchreinerMax HirschCharles Schwartz10 F2:04.60$4,5501927Whiskery3Raymond WorkmanFred HopkinsHarry Payne Whitney10 F2:04.00$4,9251926Black Maria3Laverne FatorWilliam H. KarrickWilliam R. Coe10 F2:02.80$4,5751925Aga Khan4Earl SandeJames E. FitzsimmonsBelair Stud10 F2:04.00$5,2001924Spot Cash4Edward ScobieJames W. HealyAlbert C. Bostwick Jr.10 F2:05.60$5,8501910 – 1923 Race not held1909Olambala3James ButwellT. J. HealeyMontpelier Stable10 F2:05.00$2,3001908Dorante3James LeeRaleigh ColstonFred A. Forsythe10 F2:03.40$2,3001907Nealon4Willie KnappFrank M. TaylorPatchogue Stable (William DuBois)10 F2:05.60$12,8001906Fine Cloth3Guy GarnerBarry D. WoodThomas L. Watt10 F2:07.00$14,0551905Wild Mint3David NicolJames G. Rowe Sr.James R. Keene10 F2:06.80$6,1221904Caughnawaga5Tommy BurnsHubert H. HynerJohn Sanford10 F2:05.00$12,4001903McChesney4Grover FullerFrank M. TaylorEdward E. Smathers10 F2:04.60$6,2501902Gunfire3Harry CochranJohn E. MaddenWilliam C. Whitney10 F2:05.20$6,0001901Herbert4Lewis SmithWalter C. RollinsWalter C. Rollins10 F2:07.00$5,3001900Ethelbert4Henry SpencerA. Jack JoynerPerry Belmont & Anthony L. Aste10 F2:07.00$4,6001899Previous4Winfield O'ConnorJulius BauerBromley & Co. (Joseph E. Bromley & Arthur Featherstone)10 F2:10.00$5,0501898The Friar4Fred LittlefieldR. Wyndham WaldenAlfred H. & Dave H. Morris10 F2:07.40$3,8501897Ornament3Fred TaralCharles T. PattersonCharles T. Patterson10 F2:05.40$3,8501896Requital3Alonzo ClaytonJames G. Rowe Sr.Brookdale Stable10 F2:10.20$1,6751895Rey El Santa Anita4Fred TaralHenry McDanielLucky Baldwin10 F2:07.00$1,6351894Dorian3Anthony HamiltonJohn W. RogersJohn W. Rogers10 F2:08.20$2,4751893Galindo4E. MorrisDow L. WilliamsLucky Baldwin10 F2:09.00$2,5801892Lamplighter3Anthony HamiltonJohn Huggins Pierre Lorillard IV10 F2:09.20$7,3501891Strathmeath3George CovingtonGreen B. MorrisGreen B. Morris10 F2:10.60$3,3901890Firenze6Edward GarrisonMatthew ByrnesJames Ben Ali Haggin10 F2:07.00$3,7351889Exile7Anthony HamiltonWilliam LakelandWilliam Lakeland10 F2:09.80$4,7251888Exile6Anthony HamiltonWilliam LakelandWilliam Lakeland10 F2:08.00$4,4601887Elkwood4William J. FitzpatrickJames B. DyerWalter Gratz10 F2:08.00$4,4201886Louisette5Anthony HamiltonLocust Stable10 F2:12.25$4,2451885Bersan3William J. FitzpatrickGreen B. MorrisGreen B. Morris & James D. Patton10 F2:12.50$4,4021884Tom Martin3George ChurchPeter C. Fox10 F2:10.25$4,367
References