James Borthwick of Stow (1615 – 1675) was a Scottish surgeon who was the first teacher of anatomy in the Incorporation of Surgeons and Barbers of Edinburgh. He was Deacon (President) of the Incorporation on two occasions and a member of the Scottish Parliament. Borthwick was largely responsible for the formal creation of the surgeon-apothecary in Edinburgh.
Early life and admission to the Incorporation of Surgeons James Borthwick inherited the estate of Stow south of Edinburgh. He served his apprenticeship as an apothecary and was admitted to the Incorporation of Surgeons in 1645 without first having served a surgical apprenticeship, an unusual event at that time. It is likely this exception was granted because the membership of the Incorporation had been reduced by plague.Macintyre, IMC. and MacLaren IF. Surgeons Lives The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. Edinburgh 2005 p.28 The College minutes of 7 December 1646 record that he was admitted 'through ye decrease of certain masters in ye common visitation.'Cresswell, CH. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. Oliver & Boyd. Edinburgh, 1926 p.34 It seems likely that his admission was arranged specifically so that he could teach anatomy to the surgical apprentices, the first member to have this responsibility.
Surgical career Borthwick's duties included performing anatomical dissections for the instruction of apprentices.Dingwall, H. Physicians, Surgeons and Apothecaries East Lothian, Tuckwell Press, 1995. p.72 His admission and appointment as anatomy teacher appear to have been facilitated by Alexander Pennycuik with whom he had served as a surgeon with the army overseas and who was Deacon of the Incorporation at the time of Borthwick’s appointment.Dingwall, H. Physicians, Surgeons and Apothecaries East Lothian, Tuckwell Press, 1995
This was the first time that the Incorporation had designated a specific teacher of anatomy and his appointment may be regarded as the first appointment in the Edinburgh extramural school of medicine..
Borthwick, having served time as an apothecary, introduced the teaching of pharmacy into the Incorporation, an addition to the surgeons repertoire which reduced the decline in the fortunes of the Incorporation by making a surgical career more attractive.Cresswell, CH. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. Oliver & Boyd. Edinburgh, 1926 p.113
He was responsible, jointly, with Thomas Kincaid for the act of the Town Council which, in 1657, brought the Surgeon- Apothecary into being in Edinburgh.Cresswell, CH. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. Oliver & Boyd. Edinburgh, 1926 p.36 Up until then the surgeons and apothecaries had different areas of practice, the surgeons being responsible for treating tumours, wounds, ulcers and fractures while the apothecaries were involved in dispensing medicines. After the 1657 Act it became possible to combine these skills as a surgeon-apothecary. This was ratified by Act of the Scottish Parliament in 1670.Dingwall, H. Physicians, Surgeons and Apothecaries East Lothian, Tuckwell Press, 1995. p. 189
In 1647 he rented rooms in Dickson's Close, Edinburgh, which provided the first regular meeting place for the surgeons.Cresswell, CH. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. Oliver & Boyd. Edinburgh, 1926 p.36
His apprentices included William Borthwick of Pilmuir, the first of the Edinburgh surgeons known to have studied medicine at Padua and Leiden after admission to Fellowship.
James Borthwick was Deacon of the Incorporation from 1648 to 1651 and again from 1659 to 1661. He was a member of the Scottish Parliament representing Edinburgh. His portrait in the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh is the oldest in the College.Cresswell, CH. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. Oliver & Boyd. Edinburgh, 1926 p.94
Addition lands and property around Stow we gifted to him in 1670, an event ratified by the Scottish Parliament.Brown, KM. et al.(eds) The Records of the Parliaments of Scotland to 1707. Ratification in favour of James Borthwick of Stow[1670/7/52] St Andrews, 2007-2017. http://www.rps.ac.uk/search.php?action=print&id=39008&filename=charlesii_trans&type=trans
Death and burial
Borthwick died in 1676 and is buried in Greyfriars Churchyard in Edinburgh, where his grave is marked by an imposing mural monument, erected by his son.Brown, James, The Epitaphs and Monumental Inscriptions in Greyfriars (1867) Edinburgh, J.Moodie Millar This is almost four metres high and two metres wide and features in its centre a full size dancing skeleton carrying a scythe representing the King of Terrors, armed with the scythe of Father Time. Below the skeleton is a crown denoting righteousness. Below this is a carved skull and cross bones, while the side panels have carvings of surgical instruments. The Latin inscription that was placed on the monument is no longer legible,Canmore SC560159. Detail of main panel of tomb to James Borthwick dated 1676 https://canmore.org.uk/collection/560159 but Robert Monteith was able to record it. The inscription translates as: 'To the memory of his father, James Borthwick of Stow, lawful son of the Cruixtoun family, most famous Chirurgeon Apothecary, Mr James Borthwick his eldest son in a mournful mind placed this monument.'Golledge, Charlotte. Greyfriars Graveyard (2018) Amberley Publishers.
References