This is a list of recipients of the Professional Footballers' Association Scotland (PFA Scotland) Player's Player of the Year award for each of the three divisions (the Scottish Championship, Scottish League One and Scottish League Two), below the top division (the Scottish Premiership). Each is an annual award given to the player who is adjudged to have been the best of the season in Scottish football. The winner is chosen by a vote amongst the members of the players' trade union, the Professional Footballers' Association Scotland (PFA Scotland).

The award was formerly known as the Scottish Professional Footballers' Association Players' Player of the Year, but was renamed after the SPFA merged with the (English) Professional Footballers' Association to become PFA Scotland. In 2007 the SPFA was replaced by a new body, PFA Scotland, but the new organisation's awards are considered to be a direct continuation of the SPFA awards. A shortlist of nominees is published in April and the winner of the award, along with the winners of PFA Scotland's other annual awards, is announced at a gala event in Glasgow a few days later.

Winners

Season Scottish Championship Scottish League One Scottish League Two Ref Nat Player Club Nat Player Club Nat Player Club 1980–81 Eric Sinclair Dundee Jimmy Robertson Queen of the South division did not exist 1981–82 Brian McLaughlin Motherwell Pat Nevin Clyde 1982–83 Gerry McCabe Clydebank John Colquhoun Stirling Albion 1983–84 Forfar Athletic 1984–85 Bernie Slaven Albion Rovers 1985–86 John Brogan Hamilton Accies Mark Smith Queen's Park 1986–87 Jimmy Holmes Greenock Morton John Sludden Ayr United 1987–88 Alex Taylor Hamilton Academical Henry Templeton 1988–89 Ross Jack Dunfermline Athletic Paul Hunter East Fife (via) British Newspaper Archive. 1989–90 Ken Eadie Clydebank Willie Watters Kilmarnock (via) British Newspaper Archive. 1990–91 Simon Stainrod Falkirk Kevin Todd Berwick Rangers. (via) British Newspaper Archive. 1991–92 Gordon Dalziel Raith Rovers Andy Thomson Queen of the South 1992–93 Sandy Ross Brechin City 1993–94 Richard Cadette Falkirk Andy Thomson Queen of the South 1994–95 Stevie Crawford Raith Rovers Greenock Morton Forfar Athletic 1995–96 George O'Boyle St Johnstone Steve McCormick Stirling Albion Jason Young Livingston 1996–97 Roddy Grant Hamilton Accies Inverness CT 1997–98 Dundee Clydebank Alloa Athletic 1998–99 Hibernian Livingston Ross County Magician disappears ; Trinidad Guardian, 10 May 2006 1999–2000 Stevie Crawford Dunfermline Athletic Brian Carrigan Clyde Steven Milne Forfar Athletic 2000–01 Livingston Partick Thistle East Stirlingshire 2001–02 Airdrieonians Queen of the South East Fife 2002–03 Inverness CT Brechin City Greenock Morton 2003–04 Clyde Forfar Athletic Stranraer 2004–05 Falkirk Brechin City Getna 2005–06 Ross County Gretna Markus Paatelainen Cowdenbeath 2006–07 Gretna Brechin City Albion Rovers 2007–08 Livingston Airdrie United East Fife 2008–09 Ayr United Albion Rovers 2009–10 Inverness CT Brechin City Livingston 2010–11 Raith Rovers Arbroath 2011–12 Falkirk Cowdenbeath Alloa Athletic 2012–13 Queen of the South Rangers 2013–14 Cowdenbeath Rangers Peterhead 2014–15 Hibernian Greenock Morton Arbroath 2015–16 Rangers Dunfermline Athletic East Fife 2016–17 Hibernian Livingston Elgin City 2017–18 St Mirren Ayr United Stirling Albion 2018–19 Stephen Dobbie Queen of the South Bobby Linn Arbroath Blair Henderson Edinburgh City 2019–20Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, PFA Scotland cancelled their awards for the 2019–20 season. 2020–21 Liam Boyce Heart of Midlothian not awarded not awarded 2021–22 Michael McKenna Arbroath Dylan Easton Airdrieonians Joe Cardle Kelty Hearts 2022–23 Dipo Akinyemi Ayr United Calum Gallagher Airdrieonians Charlie Reilly Albion Rovers 2023–24 Brian Graham Partick Thistle Callumn Morrison Falkirk Gregor Buchanan Stenhousemuir 2024–25 Brad Spencer Falkirk Fraser Taylor Arbroath Alan Trouten East Fife 2025–26 Josh McPake St Johnstone Oli Shaw Hamilton Academical John Robertson East Kilbride

List of other nominees