Thomas Carmichael (October 12, 1830 – October 13, 1902) was an Irish-American lumberman and politician from Eau Claire, Wisconsin, who spent four discontinuous terms as a member of the Wisconsin State Assembly."Members of the Wisconsin Legislature 1848–1999 State of Wisconsin Legislative Bureau. Information Bulletin 99-1, September 1999. p. 35
Background Carmichael was born in Kings County, Ireland on October 12, 1830 and was educated in the Irish National Schools. He emigrated to the United States in 1851, becoming a lumberman and settling for some time in Unadilla, New York, before moving in 1857 to Wisconsin, and eventually settling in Eau Claire.
Upon the outbreak of the American Civil War, he helped fund a company for the 17th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry Regiment, but they were not organized in time to enlist in the 17th. He and the 35 men he had enlisted left for St. Louis, where they joined the 10th Wisconsin Light Artillery Battery,Kelly, Bill. "One Third of Adult Males in This Area in Service During 1861; Chippewa River Main Artery to Outside World" Daily Telegram March 3, 1862; p. 11, col. 1 with Carmichael becoming a private. He took part in sieges and battles at Corinth, Murfreesboro, Tennessee, and several minor battles in which the Army of the Cumberland was involved up to the surrender of Chattanooga. He was promoted to 1st Lieutenant in the newly-organized 37th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry Regiment, and served on recruiting and other detached service until he was discharged in October 1864, due to an unspecified illness from which he never fully recovered.
Public office Upon the 1872 organization of the City of Eau Claire, Carmichael became alderman for his Ward; he also served on the Eau Claire County Board of Supervisors. He was a delegate to the 1873 Democratic state convention, and was elected that year to the Assembly's Eau Claire County seat as a member of the Liberal Reform Party (a short-lived coalition of Democrats, reform and Liberal Republicans, and Grangers which secured the election of one Governor of Wisconsin, as well as electing a number of state legislators), defeating Republican William P. Bartlett with 1,065 votes to 851 for Bartlett. He was assigned to the standing committees on lumber and manufactures; and on the militia.Turner, A. J., ed. The legislative manual of the state of Wisconsin: comprising the constitutions of the United States and of the state of Wisconsin, Jefferson's manual, forms and laws for the regulation of business; also, lists and tables for reference, etc. Thirteenth Annual Edition. Madison: Atwood and Culver, Printers and Stereotypers, 1874; pp. 350, 459, 474, 479 He did not run for re-election, and was replaced the next year by Republican Jonathan G. Callahan.
In 1876 he was once again elected to the Assembly, this time as a Democrat, with 2,101 votes to 1,905 for Republican C. C. Miller (Republican incumbent Hobart Stocking was not a candidate). He was assigned to the standing committee on state affairs.Bashford, R. M., ed. The legislative manual of the state of Wisconsin: comprising the constitutions of the United States and of the state of Wisconsin, Jefferson's manual, forms and laws for the regulation of business; also, lists and tables for reference, etc. Sixteenth Annual Edition. Madison: E. B. Bolens, State Printer, 1877; pp. 208, 297, 460, 481, 487 He was not a candidate for re-election in 1877, and was succeeded by Republican Julius Ingram.
In 1880 he was the Democratic candidate for his old seat, losing to Republican incumbent Ira B. Bradford with 1725 votes to Bradford's 2,263.Heg, J. E., ed. The Blue Book of the State of Wisconsin, Madison, 1881; p. 509 In 1881, Bradford was not a candidate, and Carmichael, the Democratic nominee, reclaimed his old seat with 1872 votes to 1,147 for Republican N. C. Foster. He was assigned to the committee on privileges and elections.Heg, J. E., ed. The Blue Book of the State of Wisconsin, Madison, 1881; pp. 545-46, 572 In 1882 he was re-elected, not as a Democrat but as an anti-monopoly candidate, with 1,165 votes, to 1062 for Republican John Hunner, 795 for the Democratic nominee L. R. Larson, and 446 for Prohibitionist C. R. Kellerman. He chose to join the Democrats in the Assembly, and was not only assigned once more to the committee lumber and manufactures but assigned as its chairman.Heg, J. E., ed. The Blue Book of the State of Wisconsin, Madison, 1883; pp. 490, 516 He was not a candidate for re-election in 1883, and was succeeded by Republican John Edward Williams.
After his last term Carmichael was selected a delegate to the 1884 state Democratic convention."Eau Claire" St. Paul Globe September 11, 1884; p. 2, col. 7 He remained active as a lumberman (the legislature being very much a part-time occupation in that era);"Tax-Title Decision" St. Paul Globe June 3, 1885; p. 4, col. 7 but was also much in demand as a speaker at pro-labor events."Eau Claire: Political Enthusiasm" St. Paul Globe April 10, 1886; p. 4, col. 7"Eau Claire: Knights of Labor Picnic" St. Paul Globe April 20, 1886; p. 5, col. 2 and was considered a spokesman for the "workingmen" faction within the Democratic Party (who did not, in his stated opinion, need or want to run a third party at this time)"Eau Claire" St. Paul Globe July 5, 1886; p. 5, col. 2"Eau Claire" St. Paul Globe August 18, 1886; p. 5, col. 2 and for the labor movement."Labor and Capital Consult" St. Paul Globe August 13, 1886; p. 5, col. 1
As of 1890 he had apparently given up on the Democratic Party;"Badger Political Notes" Weekly Wisconsin October 11, 1890; p. 1, col. 5 in that year, he ran for the Eau Claire Assembly seat again, as a Union Labor candidate, coming in third in a four-way race.Cunningham, Thomas J., ed. The Blue Book of the State of Wisconsin, Madison, 1891; p. 590 In 1892, with Eau Claire having been divided into two districts, he ran in the first district as a Populist, coming in fourth in another four-way race.Cunningham, Thomas J., ed. The Blue Book of the State of Wisconsin, Madison, 1893; p. 640
In 1896 he was among the members of the Wisconsin unit of the Silver Party who supported the endorsement of the Democratic/Populist electoral fusion strategy and nomination of William Jennings Bryant."Wisconsin Silver Men; Resolutions Adopted at Their Convention in Milwaukee" Logansport Reporter July 16, 1896; p. 1, col. 3
Death and aftermath Carmichael died on the afternoon of October 13, 1902 in Eau Claire."State Notes" Janesville Daily Gazette October 14, 1902; p. 1, col. 5 He left an extensive estate, including land in nine Wisconsin counties, the city of Eau Claire, Itasca County, Minnesota, and Brown County, South Dakota, valued at US $60,000. Some time in 1902, three former business associates of Carmichael's discovered that he had left a single living relative, an elderly sister living in Edenderry, Ireland. One of them, John A. Jacobs, travelled to Ireland and purchased the sister's rights in the estate for £2,620. The information was cabled to the United States, and the trio obtained court orders blocking any sale of lands in the Carmichael estate. The subsequent lawsuits would be tied up in courts through 1909."Almost Like Romance: John A. Jacob Travels to Ireland in Interests of Carmichael Estate: Restraining Order Issued to Prevent Sale of Lands" Eau Claire Leader December 14, 1904; p. 5, col. 1"County Court Matters" Eau Claire Leader July 4, 1905; p. 3, col. 2"The City" Eau Claire Leader August 3, 1909; p. 8, col. 2
References