The 2004–05 season was Port Vale's 93rd season of football in the English Football League, and first in the newly created League One. It was Martin Foyle's first full season in charge after succeeding Brian Horton midway through the previous campaign. The club endured a relegation scrap but ultimately secured 18th place with 56 points, ensuring safety despite the loss of key performers Stephen McPhee and Steve Brooker over the summer.

Port Vale struggled to make an impact in cup competitions. They were eliminated in the First Round of the League Cup, suffered defeat to Blackpool in the Second Round of the FA Cup, and exited the Football League Trophy at the Second Round after a loss to Tranmere Rovers. On the field, Billy Paynter emerged as the club's top scorer with 13 goals in all competitions, while Lee Matthews also contributed ten league goals. One of the season's standout results was a 5–0 home win over Barnsley in April, although the campaign also featured heavy 4–0 losses on two occasions. Attendance remained low, with an average crowd of around 4,973, underscoring the ongoing financial challenges facing the club.

Overview League One The pre-season saw Martin Foyle add to his squad with a number of free signings: Lee Matthews (Bristol City); Jeff Smith (Bolton Wanderers); Dean Smith (Sheffield Wednesday); Daryl McMahon (West Ham United); and Robin Hulbert (Telford United). The pre-season saw Vale finish 5th in the Isle of Man tournament at The Bowl. They also managed to battle to a draw at home to La Liga club Racing de Santander.

The season started positively with ten points from five games, though until the end of the season, Vale failed to find form and picked up an average of one point a game despite only playing in five draws all season. On 14 August, Vale beat Hull City 3–2, with Brooker scoring two goals including a stoppage-time winner. At half-time at the opening game of the season at Vale Park, fans were surprised to hear an announcement over the public address system telling them not to sing songs deriding rivals Stoke City. Vale defeated Bristol City by three goals to nil on 28 August, quickly building on their lead after Craig James opened the scoring on 37 minutes. Mark Goodlad picked up an injury, allowing Jonny Brain the chance to impress between the sticks. Teenage defender James O'Connor joined on loan from Aston Villa. O'Connor made his debut on 4 September as Vale picked up their first away of the season with a 2–0 victory at Bradford City. At the end of September, star midfielder Steve Brooker was sold to Bristol City for £225,000. The club failed to bring in Christian Roberts in return, though Marc Goodfellow was signed on a four-week loan deal the following month. In November, Andreas Lipa returned to his homeland to play for Austria Lustenau, after Foyle released the injury-plagued defender. McMahon also left the club to join Leyton Orient. Foyle brought a new signing to Vale Park though, with striker Nathan Lowndes joining on a free transfer from Plymouth Argyle. In December, defender Tyrone Loran joined on a one-month loan from Tranmere Rovers, though returned to Prenton Park when the loan deal was up, after Foyle failed to sign him permanently. Christian Hanson was also signed from non-League Billingham Synthonia. Foyle also signed Nigerian defender George Abbey, who had been released by Macclesfield Town.

On 3 January, Matthews scored both of the goals as Vale won 2–0 away at Blackpool, ending a run of six defeats in seven games. Dean Smith retired as a player and took up coaching at Leyton Orient. As a replacement, former Vale player Tommy Widdrington joined until the end of the season on non-contract terms. In February, veteran midfielder Danny Sonner joined on a one-month loan from Peterborough United. On 19 March, Vale beat Walsall 2–0 at home despite injuries severely limited the availability of fit players, with full-back Steve Rowland stepping up to play an excellent game in a centre-back partnership with Sam Collins. In March, club legend and former teammate of Foyle, Tony Naylor, joined on an emergency short-term contract, though never took to the field. Tony Dinning also was signed on loan from Bristol City. In addition to this, Mark Innes joined on a free transfer from Chesterfield. Sonner's loan deal was also extended until the end of the season, at which point he was signed permanently, as was Dinning. Vale lost to fellow relegation strugglers Torquay United and Wrexham in the last five games of the season, though a 5–0 win over Barnsley ensured the club's safety from the drop.

They finished in 18th place with 56 points, leaving them five points clear of relegated Torquay. Their 59 goals conceded was a highly respectable tally, however, they failed to score in almost half of their league games, and only recorded five draws all season. Vale lost more games and scored fewer goals than all clubs in the division other than Peterborough United and Stockport County, who were both cut adrift early in the season. Billy Paynter was the club's top-scorer with 13 goals, with other contributions also coming from Lee Matthews and Chris Birchall.

At the end of the season teenage prodigy David Hibbert was snapped up by Preston North End, who paid Vale £35,000 after a tribunal. Four players were also released: Simon Eldershaw (Northwich Victoria); Christian Hanson (Billingham Synthonia); Levi Reid (Stafford Rangers); and Ryan Brown (Leek Town). Ian Armstrong also retired due to injury.

Finances On the financial front, Chairman Bill Bratt announced there was a 50-50 chance that an elderly American would put funds into the club. However, the investment did not come through. Bratt also went public with his idea of Reginald Mitchell Stadium in honour of the inventor of the Spitfire, hopeful that 85-year-old American billionaire Sidney Frank would thus be encouraged to invest in the club. Foyle was desperate for more funds to attract better players, and was forced to dismiss speculation that he would sell Billy Paynter to Crewe Alexandra. On 13 December, shareholders voted by a margin of 119 to 3 to limit individual holdings in the club to a maximum of 24.9% "to ensure that no single shareholder can acquire undue influence or control over the company", in the words of Bill Bratt.What If There Had Been No Port In The Vale?: Startling Port Vale Stories! p. 181 (Witan Books, 2011, ) The club's shirt sponsorship came from mobile phone company Tricell. However, the firm could not afford to pay the club any money as they entered administration, worsening an already bleak financial picture for the "Valiants".

Cup competitions In the FA Cup, Vale avoided embarrassment by coming from behind to defeat local side Kidderminster Harriers 3–1. They then lost out to Blackpool in the second round with a 1–0 defeat at Bloomfield Road.

In the League Cup, Vale travelled to Belle Vue, where they were knocked out by Doncaster Rovers after a 3–1 defeat.

In the Football League Trophy, the "Valiants" advanced past Barnsley in front of a Vale Park crowd of just 1,970. However, they then exited at the second round after a 2–1 defeat to Tranmere Rovers at Prenton Park.

Results Pre-season

Football League One League table

Results by matchday

Matches

FA Cup

League Cup

Football League Trophy

Squad statistics

Appearances and goals Key to positions: GK – Goalkeeper; DF – Defender; MF – Midfielder; FW – Forward

|colspan="14"|Players who featured but departed the club during the season:

Top scorers PlacePositionNationNumberNameLeague OneFA CupLeague CupFootball League TrophyTotal1FW10Billy Paynter10201132FW7Lee Matthews10000103MF17Chris Birchall600174FW9Steve Brooker500055MF15Ian Armstrong30003–MF12Tony Dinning300037MF8Micky Cummins20002–DF6Sam Collins20002–FW21David Hibbert2000210DF3Craig James10001–MF11Jeff Smith10001–FW19Simon Eldershaw10001–FW9Nathan Lowndes10001–DF12Dean Smith00101–MF13Levi Reid01001–––Own goals20002TOTALS4931255

Transfers

Transfers in Date from Position Nationality Name From Fee Ref. June 2004 FW Lee Matthews Bristol City Free transfer June 2004 MF Jeff Smith Bolton Wanderers Free transfer July 2004 MF Robin Hulbert Telford United Free transfer July 2004 DF Dean Smith Sheffield Wednesday Free transfer September 2004 MF Daryl McMahon West Ham United Non-contract terms November 2004 FW Nathan Lowndes Plymouth Argyle Free transfer December 2004 DF Christian Hanson Billingham Synthonia Free transfer December 2004 MF Andy Porter Kidsgrove Athletic Free transfer January 2005 MF Tommy Widdrington Hartlepool United Non-contract terms March 2005 DF Mark Innes Chesterfield Free transfer

Transfers out Date from Position Nationality Name To Fee Ref. September 2004 FW Steve Brooker Bristol City £225,000 November 2004 DF Andreas Lipa Austria Lustenau Free transfer November 2004 MF Daryl McMahon Leyton Orient Free transfer December 2004 DF George Abbey Macclesfield Town Free transfer January 2005 DF Dean Smith Released May 2005 DF Ryan Brown Leek Town Released May 2005 FW Simon Eldershaw Northwich Victoria Released May 2005 DF Christian Hanson Billingham Synthonia Released May 2005 MF Levi Reid Stafford Rangers Released May 2005 MF Tommy Widdrington Salisbury City Released June 2005 FW David Hibbert Preston North End £35,000 Summer 2005 MF Ian Armstrong Retired

Loans in Date from Position Nationality Name From Date to Ref. 4 September 2004 DF James O'Connor Aston Villa 4 December 2004 4 October 2004 MF Marc Goodfellow Bristol City 4 November 2004 2 December 2004 DF Tyrone Loran Tranmere Rovers 4 January 2005 21 February 2005 MF Danny Sonner Peterborough United End of season 22 March 2005 MF Tony Dinning Bristol City End of season

Loans out Date from Position Nationality Name To Date to Ref. 7 April 2005 GK Joe Anyon Stafford Rangers End of season

References Specific

General Soccerbase